Among the local solicitor and boutique agents we compared, Harbour & Key comes last on search.
example-property.co.uk · measured on 8 July 2026, prepared by Robin Laires.
- What we found
- Harbour & Key describes itself as the largest firm of solicitor estate agents in East Central Scotland by sales volume and listings. On search, it comes last of the five local agents we compared.
- Why it matters
- These are the firms a seller may compare it with. In seller AI answers, ESPC is named in 17 of 32, McEwan Fraser Legal in 13, and Harbour & Key in 4.
- What could help
- Putting effort into the questions sellers ask before choosing an agent, such as cost, could be a better use of time than competing with the portals on listings terms.
Estimated organic visits a month
On search, Harbour & Key sits at the bottom of the local group on every measure: 1,181 ranking keywords against Rettie's 23,320, and an estimated 5,783 organic visits a month against Rettie's 345,350. From what we can see, the business doing the most volume on the ground is doing the least volume in search.
Property portals and national online agents
| Competitor | Ranking keywords | Est. organic visits a month | Top-3 keywords |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purplebricks | 117,112 | 903,857 | 1,553 |
| Yopa | 47,439 | 630,235 | 1,036 |
| ESPC | 30,604 | 650,903 | 3,167 |
ESPC, Purplebricks and Yopa work at a different scale, with 30,604 to 117,112 ranking keywords each, built on portal-style listing volume and national reach. These three are unlikely to be out-ranked for “property for sale edinburgh” or similar listings terms, and trying could take effort away from the searches Harbour & Key can win.
Local hybrids: solicitor and boutique estate agents
| Competitor | Ranking keywords | Est. organic visits a month | Top-3 keywords |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rettie | 23,320 | 345,350 | 1,717 |
| McEwan Fraser Legal | 5,741 | 49,106 | 395 |
| Gilson Gray | 4,228 | 39,509 | 181 |
| Warners | 1,628 | 12,535 | 59 |
| Harbour & Key Property | 1,181 | 5,783 | 36 |
In this group, Harbour & Key is last on every column: 1,181 keywords, an estimated 5,783 organic visits a month, and 36 top-3 keyword positions (9 at #1 and 27 more at #2 to #3, from the wider organic capture). Warners, the smallest of the other four, ranks for 1,628 keywords worth an estimated 12,535 organic visits a month, more than double Harbour & Key's figure.
These are the firms Harbour & Key competes with for a seller instruction: same model, same city, same kind of client. Warners and Gilson Gray are ahead on visibility, while Harbour & Key does more business than either on the ground. From what we can see, the gap is in how easily Harbour & Key is found.
Who the AI tools name instead, on the 32 seller-intent answers
| Competitor | Named in seller AI answers | Note |
|---|---|---|
| ESPC | 17 of 32 | The portal itself, and also the most-cited domain in ChatGPT's own branded answers about Harbour & Key |
| McEwan Fraser Legal | 13 of 32 | Another solicitor estate agent, with direct overlap in positioning |
| Neilsons | 12 of 32 | Also in the Maps pack on 2 of the 5 local searches (4.8, 194 reviews) |
| Rettie | 10 of 32 | Named in both organic results and AI answers |
| Warners | 10 of 32 | Solicitor estate agent, same model as Harbour & Key |
| Gilson Gray | 9 of 32 | Solicitor estate agent, same model as Harbour & Key |
| Coulters | 7 of 32 | Organic only, and strong on the seller searches |
| Purplebricks | 6 of 32 | National online agent, with positioning close to fixed fee |
| Yopa | 5 of 32 | National online agent, with positioning close to fixed fee |
| Harbour & Key Property | 4 of 32 | For comparison: the business this audit covers |
Across the 32 seller-intent answers, ESPC is named 17 times, McEwan Fraser Legal 13, Neilsons 12, Rettie and Warners 10 each, and Gilson Gray 9. Harbour & Key is named 4 times. These are questions a seller may be asking before choosing who to instruct.
From what we can see, the AI tools are not reading Harbour & Key's website to build these answers. They draw on agentseeker.co.uk, yably.co.uk, allagents.co.uk, Reddit, Trustpilot and review round-ups, and Harbour & Key's volume on the ground may not reach the sources they cite.
The one place Harbour & Key is already named
“Who should I sell my flat with in Edinburgh” names Harbour & Key in both ChatGPT and Perplexity. Gemini names it for “fixed fee estate agent scotland” and “best estate agent in edinburgh for selling a flat”. The £600 fixed fee is the one angle where Harbour & Key is already named ahead of firms with many times its search size, which suggests the position is winnable.
The seller-decision questions, more than the portals
Zoopla, Rightmove, ESPC and OnTheMarket dominate their own keyword space, which is property listings. The ground Harbour & Key might win is the seller-decision and cost questions: “which estate agent should I use in Edinburgh”, “how much does it cost to sell a house in Scotland” and “fixed fee vs percentage estate agent”.
That is where the £600 fixed fee, the 4.6 rating from 662 reviews and the solicitor-plus-agent model could do the work: on Harbour & Key's own /fees/ page, in schema, and on the aggregator and listicle sites the AI tools already trust more than any agent's own website.
Competitor figures are domain overviews captured on 8 July 2026. Ranking keywords, organic visits and top-3 keywords are estimates. The AI figures come from 32 seller-intent answers from ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Claude. AI answers vary between runs, so a single run is a snapshot.