01 · Overview

Harbour & Key has 662 Google reviews at 4.6, and it could show up in more places on Google and in AI tools.

example-property.co.uk · measured on 8 July 2026, prepared by Robin Laires.

The short version
What we found
Harbour & Key has more Google reviews than any Edinburgh agent we measured, but it is not in the top 20 on Maps and is named in 4 of 32 seller AI answers.
Why it matters
Maps and AI answers are places a seller may look when choosing who to sell with.
What could help
Reworking the Business Profile, adding page headings and structured data, and getting listed on the sites the AI tools read could help most.
Overall
22 / 44
50%

Reviews and branded AI answers both score full marks. Six of the eleven areas are at 1 of 4: Maps rankings, seller AI answers, searches that matter, mobile speed, headings and titles, and structured data. Each area is scored 0 to 4, with no weighting.

Maps rankings
1 / 4
Branded AI answers
4 / 4
Seller AI answers
1 / 4
Searches that matter
1 / 4
Search breadth
2 / 4
Mobile speed
1 / 4
Headings and titles
1 / 4
Structured data
1 / 4
Content library
3 / 4
Backlinks
3 / 4
Reviews
4 / 4
662
Google reviews at 4.6, the most of any Edinburgh agent we measured
0 of 5
Maps searches with Harbour & Key in the top 20
4 of 32
Seller AI answers that name Harbour & Key
0 of 8
AI Overviews that cite Harbour & Key (shown on 8 of 12 searches)
16.7 s
Time until the homepage's main content shows on a phone (target 2.5 s)
42 of 53
Core pages with no H1 heading
What is working

What is already going well

AreaWhat we saw
Branded AI answersAsked about Harbour & Key by name, ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Claude all answered accurately and positively in 8 of 8 prompts, drawing on the site, allagents.co.uk and Trustpilot.
ReviewsHarbour & Key has 662 Google reviews at 4.6, more than ESPC (648), VMH (321) or Neilsons (194). Maps and the AI tools draw on this kind of signal, and it is doing little work so far.
Content libraryAbout 550 articles since 2012, with some rankings already: “best areas to live in edinburgh” at #17, the LIFT scheme guide at #16, “offer in region of meaning” at #11 and home report questions at #14 to #17.
The fixed fee angle“Who should I sell my flat with in Edinburgh” names Harbour & Key in both ChatGPT and Perplexity. Gemini names it for “fixed fee estate agent scotland” and “best estate agent in edinburgh for selling a flat”. That suggests the position is winnable.
Access and trackingGPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ClaudeBot and PerplexityBot all get a 200 response, robots.txt is open, desktop speed is fine at 82/100, and GTM and GA4 are both present.
Findings

Six things we found

Detail on the page named in each row
01

Harbour & Key is not in the top 20 on Maps for any of the 5 searches we tried.

critical

The searches were “estate agents” from Edinburgh, Glasgow and Musselburgh, “solicitor estate agents” Edinburgh and “fixed fee estate agents” Edinburgh. The packs went to Neilsons (4.8/194), Umega, Warners, McEwan Fraser and VMH (4.9/321), despite 662 reviews at 4.6. The single Profile sits at a South Gyle business park on the western edge of the city.

What could help

Reworking the Business Profile (primary category, services, the £600 fee in the description, photos, weekly posts), and asking for reviews at settlement.

Google Maps
02

AI tools name Harbour & Key in 4 of 32 seller answers.

critical

ESPC is named in 17, McEwan Fraser in 13, Neilsons in 12, and Rettie and Warners in 10 each. Google's AI Overviews appeared on 8 of 12 searches and cited Harbour & Key on none. From what we can see, the tools build these answers from agentseeker.co.uk, yably.co.uk, allagents, getagent, top10propertyagents, Reddit and Trustpilot, and mostly not from agents' own websites.

What could help

Profiles on the sites the AI tools read: getagent.co.uk, agentseeker.co.uk, yably.co.uk, a refreshed allagents.co.uk profile, and the “best estate agent Edinburgh” round-ups.

AI search
03

Harbour & Key is outside the top 30 on all 8 seller searches we tried.

critical

The only rankings on these terms are national informational searches at 27 to 32: “fixed fee estate agent scotland” at 27, “how to sell a house in scotland” at 28 and “do i need a solicitor to sell my house in scotland” at 32. Also, 356 of the top 500 ranked keywords come from /property/ listing pages, which expire when the property sells.

What could help

Rebuilding /fees/ as the page for “cost of selling a house in Scotland”, with a 40 to 60 word direct answer, the £600 figure and a comparison with percentage fees.

Google search
04

42 of 53 core pages have no H1 heading.

critical

52 of 53 have no meta description, and 8 builder partnership pages plus the listings hub have an empty title tag. /fees/, the page that carries the £600 story, is 962 words, titled “Our Fees - Harbour & Key”, with no structured data. Headings and titles are often the first things Google and AI tools quote.

What could help

H1s, titles and meta descriptions on the 53 core pages, and titles for the 8 builder pages.

Technical
05

The site has no structured data that says Harbour & Key is an estate agent.

critical

Across the 231 pages crawled, there is no RealEstateAgent or LocalBusiness schema, no FAQPage and no Offer markup, only theme defaults. Schema is code that tells Google and AI tools what a page is. The £600 fixed fee, the 4.6 rating from 662 reviews and the solicitor-plus-agent model may be hard for them to pick up.

What could help

RealEstateAgent, Offer (the £600 fixed fee) and FAQPage schema on the homepage, /fees/, /sell/ and the guide steps.

Technical
06

In our test, the homepage took 16.7 seconds to show its main content on a phone.

critical

Mobile performance scored 44/100, with 746 KiB of unused JavaScript and a 4.0 MB page, against a 2.5 second target. Desktop scores 82/100 at 2.0 seconds, which suggests the build is the cause. Most property searches start on a phone.

What could help

Cutting the mobile JavaScript, with a first milestone of main content under 4 seconds.

Technical
A common thread

The pieces are there, and Google and the AI tools may not see them yet

From what we can see, Harbour & Key already has the reviews, about 550 articles and a £600 fixed fee. Findings 01, 03, 04 and 05 suggest these may not yet be in the places Google and the AI tools read first.

The plan suggests an order for the work, starting with the fixes that take days.

Method and limits

Measured on 8 July 2026, from Google Maps (5 searches), ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Claude (32 seller answers and 8 branded prompts), Google AI Overviews (12 searches) and a crawl of 231 pages. A single run of AI answers is noisy, so the figures are a snapshot.

Real client work. Names and locations changed.